I haven’t written for awhile, and it’s not for lack of things to say. There has been a topic, an issue, rattling around in my brain for the past week or so. It actually took up residence months ago, but I have been reticent to write about it, because it is essentially the third rail of Mommy Blogging, and I try to stay away from the really controversial issues. (You’ll notice I haven’t blogged about immunizations, and yes, I do have an opinion on the topic, and yes, I will likely write about it one of these days.) I’ve started several posts on other issues, but this particular matter has really gummed up the works, and I suspect the wheels won’t start moving until I get it out. So here goes.
I need to write about The Bad Mother. Those of you who are hooked into the Mommy Blogosphere are undoubtedly aware of this phenomenon. Even if you aren’t a Wired Mom, I’m sure you have heard a mother at a park or in school or at a store or even in your own living room refer to herself as A Bad Mother. There are countless blogs and books and articles and podcasts about The Bad Mother. (I am purposefully not linking to any of them – I don’t want to pin this donkey tail on anyone in particular. You can find them yourself if you are interested.)
For those of you who aren’t entirely sure what I am talking about, here goes. The Bad Mother Thing is a current trend in the Mommy World wherein we Mothers confess our Badness to friends, fellow mothers, and total strangers (in books, on websites, etc). Our confessions range from the banal (“I ignored my children today while I watched the finale of Dancing with the Stars”) to the common but unspoken (“I started taking anti-depressants after the baby was born”) to the just plain stupid (“I feed my baby generic formula instead of the brand-name stuff”).
Now, before I share my thoughts about The Bad Mother Phenomenon, I need to say two things. First, and most importantly, I am absolutely positively 100% guilty of almost everything I am about critique. I have felt like a Bad Mother, I have referred to myself as A Bad Mother, and I have judged other mothers for their Badness (which usually ends up biting me in the ass, not surprisingly). Secondly, my thoughts on this topic are not fully formed, but they are formed enough to be taking up space in my brain, so I welcome your thoughts and comments, as always.
Ok, here goes. Here’s my problem with the Bad Mother phenomenon –it is representative of a lack of perspective by those of us who tote the Bad Mother line, and it only serves to continue the already damaging trend of mothers judging, criticizing, and putting down other mothers. Let me ‘splain. No, there is too much. Let me sum up.
First, as far as I can remember, I haven’t ever actually read or heard a Bad Mother confession that was actually representative of Bad Mothering. I’ve heard mothers talk about making choices that other mothers might not make, and I’ve heard them talk about doing things that child development specialists and pediatricians probably wouldn’t support in their roles as child development specialists and pediatricians. (For example, I fed Choochie Floorios and floorberries, and I think she ate a decent amount of sand at the lake today.) However, I would bet my baby that if you got those people to talk to you as mothers and fathers, they would absolutely agree that they did the same thing, or worse, when they were raising their little ones. (Furthermore, any social worker could, and should, tell you all the reasons why it’s good for children to be frustrated and ignored and challenged and annoyed on a somewhat regular basis, but more on that later.)
So, why is this a problem? What’s wrong with mothers verbally acknowledging their doubts about whether or not they are making the right choices about the mundane yet real issues that arise all the time when you’re raising a baby? Not a thing, in my opinion. There’s nothing wrong with struggling with it and talking about – I think acknowledging and exploring the ups and downs of being a mother is valuable and important. My concern has to do with the context and the framing, with the label of Bad Mothering. There is a difference between questioning our own parenting styles and decisions and calling ourselves (or others) Bad Mothers.
In order to understand why this is problematic, you need to understand the context. The Bad Mother confessions tend to happen in two different ways – either through anonymous confessions published in books, websites, and blogs, or during conversations between people who have chosen to identify themselves (either in person or in writing). In my experience, those of who ascribe to the Bad Mother School (and I include myself in this) do so with pride. We wave our Bad Mother flag any chance we get – Look at me! I let my kid eat rocks! I didn’t change her diaper for six hours! I let her cry in her crib for 20 minutes while I finished reading People Magazine! I’m on anti-depressants! I put my baby in daycare! I didn’t put my baby in daycare and I’m going insane!
And the conversations continue from there, with each Bad Mother doing her best to out-Bad the other Mother. You left your baby on the bus? Yeah, well, I *put* my baby on the bus with a one-way ticket! It’s about distinguishing ourselves from Those Other Mothers, the ones who never let their kids watch TV all afternoon, and always have creative, stimulating activities for the kids, don’t let the babies go a week without a bath, and make nutritious, well-rounded meals three times a day. We may be negligent, ill-informed, bored-to-tears mothers who feed our kids Chey Boyaredee and can’t remember the words to a single nursery rhyme or song, but by g-d, at least we’re not hovering, obsessive helicopter mothers who will undoubtedly chaperone every date their kid ever has, and are just one little crazy away from moving in with the kid at college.
Yes, it’s true, who among us doesn’t love a little schadenfreude to get through the day? But dumping all of our worries and guilt into the Bad Mother Barrel is problematic in some major ways. First, and perhaps most importantly, many of the issues that are often considered Bad Mother material just aren’t. What we Bad Mothers often refer to as ignoring or neglecting our children is described in the literature as “low intrusiveness” parenting, and is linked to higher achievement in the first grade. Going on anti-depressants or getting into therapy is actually about taking care of yourself so you can care for your child, which is what good mothering is all about. Those moments when we drink a beer while the kid watches a little TV are about taking care of ourselves so we don’t fly completely off the handle, which not only prevents us from flying off aforementioned handle, but also teaches the kids that sometime she has to entertain herself while Mommy needs to take care of herself. These are important lessons for kids to learn, and there is no perfect mother. Let me just say it again – there is no perfect mother. We social workers talk a lot about The Good Enough Mother, and chances are that if your worst Bad Mother confession is about the time your kid dropped the F-Bomb at preschool, you’re a Good Enough Mother.
Even if your Bad Mother moment actually is a real Bad Mother moment, with no redeeming values, chances are that if you are involved in this dialogue, your Bad Mommy oversights are cushioned by developmentally-appropriate toys, safe and caring childcare, generally healthy food, and stimulating experiences. Thus, the Bad Mother conversations often end up being something like “Your kid fell off the bed? Dude! My kid fell out of the high chair. Whoop! Gotta run – we’re off to a Mommy and Me Music Class.”
Furthermore, as I mentioned above, even if we don’t ever blatantly bad mouth other mothers in the course of the conversation, the implication is there. We may be Bad Mothers, but at least we are Bad Mothers in small, insignificant ways. At least we’re not fundamentally fucking up our kids by turning them into prissy, entitled, overscheduled overachievers, right? The thing is, raising kids is HARD. It’s really HARD. It challenges us on almost every level, and raises issues about who we are, where we came from, who we want to be, and who we want our kids to be. Although it sounds like a cliché, I do believe that most of us are doing the best we can to keep our kids healthy, safe, and feeling loved while not going completely insane. We’re all going to have different ways of doing it, and we have to figure out what works for us. As mothers, we have a responsibility to support each other, rather than judge each other. Because nobody is going to understand the challenge of being a mother like another mother. That means something.
In addition to the “why can’t we all just get along” issue, there is the problem of perspective. When we spend our time focusing on the fact that we are Bad Mothers because we returned some of our daughter’s excessive number of birthday presents that she doesn’t need any way to buy a carseat for our son, we lose sight of the fact that Bad Mothering Actually Happens. And then when it does happen, it’s hard to know when, where, or how to talk about it. When you hear all of your friends talking about how they are such Bad Mothers because they let their babies play with dirty shoes or draw on each other, it makes it hard to talk about the more serious issues. And, often when you do, people clam up. You don’t often hear the same kind of “I’m a worse Bad Mother than you are” competition about actual Bad Mothering. “Oh really? Your daughter got second degree burns from coffee? My daughter crawled through fire once and will be scarred for life!” That kind of Bad Mother conversation just doesn’t happen, and it leaves those mothers who are actually struggling with real Bad Mother issues feeling lost and alone.
As long as I am talking about perspective, I feel compelled to point out that as an upper-middle-class White woman who has the time and resources to sit around and write blog posts, my world of Bad Mothering is incredibly limited. There are mothers who cook meth in front of their babies, who plot and discuss plans to murder the landlord while the kids are listening, who physically and sexually abuse their children, who leave them for hours locked up without food or water… the list goes on, and as a social worker, I have seen and heard countless of these stories. You might wonder what the point of even mentioning those mothers. Well, the point is, we need to keep perspective, and remember that Bad Mothers actually do exist. The dominant Bad Mother dialogue doesn’t acknowledge or respect the experiences and histories of those among us who had Bad Mothers or are struggling with being Bad Mothers, and it certainly doesn’t help any of us keep things in perspective.
So, those are my thoughts. I’d love to hear yours. In the meanwhile, I’m not going to stop talking about the craziness of motherhood, and chances are you’ll hear or read me going on about how Choochie and I were watching Wife Swap together yesterday because I just didn’t have it in me to do anything else. But hopefully, I won’t call myself a Bad Mother for doing it.
Post script: After I published this post, WordPress suggested related blog posts, including this one. I know I said I wasn’t going to link to anyone else, but this particular site illustrated my point so perfectly…